Mouth Cancer Foundation, Mouth Cancer Awareness donate online
 Return to main web site (leave the Online Support Group)   |   To support the Mouth Cancer Foundation, you can now make online donations!
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Picture of Dr Vinod K Joshi
Posted
NICE have given a preliminary negative recommendation for the use of Erbitux + radiotherapy.

As some of you may have heard, NICE has recently published the first draft of its guidance on the use of Erbitux in combination with radiation therapy for the treatment of locally or regionally advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck.This initial draft recommends that the treatment should NOT be funded on the NHS.

As we all know, there have been very few developments in the treatment of head and neck cancer over the years, so any treatment options are very important to those who could benefit. Furthermore, Erbitux has been approved for use in Scotland as well as Europe. So should this draft guidance remain unchanged, then people with head and neck cancer in England and Wales will be denied access to a treatment which is available in other areas of the UK.

I am sure that you will feel as strongly as I do that it is important that we speak out on the behalf of patients who have experienced cancer of the head and neck or who may be affected by it in the future. 24 of you voted for it being made available when I sought your views for submission to the Scottish Medicines Consortium which has approved it for patients in Scotland.

The draft is open to public consultation until 5pm on 26th February. So if you believe, like me, that it is important for patients to have access to this medicine, please register your views on this to NICE directly through this link. All the feedback on the draft which is submitted to NICE during this time is taken into account by its committee before the Guidance is issued.

Additionally, any comments that you would like to share with the Mouth cancer Foundation on this issue would be most welcome and will be taken into account in the charity’s response to NICE.

Best wishes
Vinod Coffee

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr Vinod K Joshi,


Disclaimer: Please see your own dentist/doctor for a proper diagnosis as my words should not, in any circumstances, be taken as dental/medical advice.

"If you see what is small as it sees itself, and accept what is weak for what strength it has, and use what is dim for the light it gives, then all will go well. This is called Acting Naturally."
Lao-Tsu, Tao Teh King
 
Posts: 2930 | Location: St Luke's Hospital, Bradford and Pinderfields Hospital, Wakefield | Registered: 14 December 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Fran
Posted Hide Post
C,mon everybody, lets get this signed & off to this dreadful committee who hold lives in their hands. Thanks Vinod for bringing this to our attention.
 
Posts: 260 | Location: Scotland | Registered: 15 November 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
My father was on Erbitux and it made his face break out like acne in the end this type of treatment did not work. This treatment does not work on all people unfortunatley
 
Posts: 76 | Location: USA BOSTON | Registered: 14 December 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
I had Erbitux and radiation 12 weeks ago. I interfaced with other head and neck cancer patients that were ahead of me in recovery at a time when Erbitux was not available. These patients went through horrendous complications from regular chemotherapy. The side effects of Erbitux are minimal in comparison. The statistics in the U.S. for 5yr plus survival outweigh the original therapy.

Any treatment is not 100% guaranteed but if the regimin and testing that our government puts new medications through has found this to be more beneficial statistically I cannot understand holding back on the release in England. What does this committee have to substatiate non approval?

Sandra
 
Posts: 14 | Location: Redondo Beach, CA | Registered: 06 January 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Dr Vinod K Joshi
Posted Hide Post
Hello Sandra

Our overall view on the draft is that the NICE committee has not looked at this in a pragmatic way or from the patients’ point of view. By denying access to this treatment, NICE does not truly understand the issues that are important to patients.

As NICE points out, the trial involving Erbitux resulted in robust findings that are very significant to patients in England and Wales with regard to the fact they will live months longer and will have an alternative should they not be able to tolerate chemoradiotherapy. NICE also notes that the treatment is cost effective.


We need to appeal to health professionals and patients to feedback to NICE on this draft guidance, which if unchanged, would deny access to the only new medicine in Head and Neck Cancer in many years for patients in England and Wales.

There are a small number of patients with Head and Neck Cancer who are set to lose a large amount if we do not act now.

Best wishes
Vinod Coffee

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr Vinod K Joshi,


Disclaimer: Please see your own dentist/doctor for a proper diagnosis as my words should not, in any circumstances, be taken as dental/medical advice.

"If you see what is small as it sees itself, and accept what is weak for what strength it has, and use what is dim for the light it gives, then all will go well. This is called Acting Naturally."
Lao-Tsu, Tao Teh King
 
Posts: 2930 | Location: St Luke's Hospital, Bradford and Pinderfields Hospital, Wakefield | Registered: 14 December 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Paul
Posted Hide Post
I had to go ont never had Erbitux so cannot comment
But when i had Radiotherapy and my mouth was blistered and bleeding plus the swelling they still forced on the mask Confused
I asked many times for omething to reliee the pain specially in my mouth you would have thought I was the only person having problem with radiotherapy Frowner I went on the Internet to find something for myself Banghead

apul
 
Posts: 744 | Location: London England | Registered: 06 March 2003Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of cookey
Posted Hide Post
I am a member of the Oral Cancer Foundation Group and i have seen this treatment mentioned in posts many many times by oral cancer sufferers in the United States.I find the differences between available medications and treatments quite astounding ,and i if am not mistaken drugs have to undergo rigorous testing before they become available for use in America.Surely this must mean that it is of benefit in treatment of oral cancer and as such should be available to everyone no matter what country you live in.
 
Posts: 433 | Location: Harewood West Yorkshire | Registered: 19 February 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Dr Vinod K Joshi
Posted Hide Post
ASCO: Cetuximab Plus Platinum Extends Head and Neck Cancer Survival
CHICAGO June 2 2007
quote:
The drug Erbitux prolongs survival in patients with advanced head and neck cancer by nearly three months, according to study results announced Saturday.

"This is the first systemic treatment in 25 years to show a survival benefit over platinum-based chemotherapy" for these patients, he said.

"We have now found for the first time--in a group of patients with a very poor outcome--a survival benefit that will change practice," said Dr. Jan Vermorken, oncology professor from the University of Antwerp in Belgium, in a prepared statement. The study results were unveiled at the annual American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO)conference.

The study tracked 222 patients with metastatic head and neck cancer who took Erbitux with chemotherapy, and 220 patients who took chemo without Erbitux. The Erbitux patients survived an average of 10.1 months, compared to 7.4 months for patients taking chemo without the drug.

"I was hopeful for this study but I was also very skeptical," Vermorken said at a press conference Saturday morning. He noted that head and neck cancer is notoriously difficult to treat. But he said the study exceeded the goal of prolonging survival by two months.


See also: Study: Erbitux prolongs cancer survival

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr Vinod K Joshi,


Disclaimer: Please see your own dentist/doctor for a proper diagnosis as my words should not, in any circumstances, be taken as dental/medical advice.

"If you see what is small as it sees itself, and accept what is weak for what strength it has, and use what is dim for the light it gives, then all will go well. This is called Acting Naturally."
Lao-Tsu, Tao Teh King
 
Posts: 2930 | Location: St Luke's Hospital, Bradford and Pinderfields Hospital, Wakefield | Registered: 14 December 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Dr Vinod K Joshi
Posted Hide Post
quote:

MEDIA ALERT – MOUTH CANCER DRUG MAY SOON BE AVAILABLE ON NHS
4th October 2007


Today, the Mouth Cancer Foundation came a step closer to making sure all Mouth Cancer patients have access to a new drug, currently not widely available on the NHS. The drug in question is called ‘Cetuximab’ and is a new cancer treatment available in Scotland since July 2006, but not England and Wales at present.

It is hoped that cetuximab in combination with radiotherapy can be used as an alternative in Mouth cancer patients for whom chemoradiotheraphy is in appropriate.

The charity successfully convinced the Appeal Panel of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) to ask its Appraisal Committee’s to reconsider its appraisal decision to ban the drug for head and neck cancer patients in England and Wales. The appraisal has now been returned to the Committee.
(click above link for pdf of the Result of the Appeal)

The Founder of the Mouth Cancer Foundation, Dr Vinod K Joshi, explained that the charity represented the views of its members constituting a wide population of patients with mouth cancer.

Four members of the Mouth Cancer Foundation, Mrs Brenda Brady, Mr John Spencer, Mrs Christine Piff and Mr Mike Cummins provided the Appeal Panel with personal accounts of the suffering caused by head and neck cancer and of the very unpleasant nature of their treatments. They stressed that it was important for the Institute to take patients’ views into account.

This the Appeal Panel did, and the debate centred on the efficacy of cetuximab. Currently both carboplatin and cisplatin are used for chemoradiotheraphy in the United Kingdom with horrific side effects. Carboplatin had fewer adverse effects than cisplatin, but was more likely to suppress the bone-marrow. Therefore, cisplatin was the preferred treatment. The Appraisal Committee accepted that cetuximab plus radiotherapy caused less severe adverse effects than either of the platinum-based chemoradiotherapy regimens.

The Appeal Panel considered that the Appraisal Committee had not given appropriate consideration to the issue of whether a chemoradiotherapy regimen of carboplatin alone was as effective as cisplatin, or that a regimen consisting of carboplatin plus fluorouracil would necessarily be suitable for the population identified in the decision problem in whom cisplatin was contra-indicated. The Panel found that, as a result, the Committee's conclusions were perverse in proposing a ‘carboplatin-based’ regimen for those in whom cisplatin was contra-indicated.

The Founder of the Mouth Cancer Foundation, Dr Vinod Joshi says “The Mouth Cancer Foundation is delighted that the decision has been referred back the Final Appraisal Determination to the Committee for reconsideration”.

Interviews Available: Founder of the Mouth Cancer Foundation Dr Vinod Joshi

To set up an interview please call Media Ambitions on 020 7482 3600



Thanks to all who supported us.

Best wishes
Vinod Coffee

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr Vinod K Joshi,


Disclaimer: Please see your own dentist/doctor for a proper diagnosis as my words should not, in any circumstances, be taken as dental/medical advice.

"If you see what is small as it sees itself, and accept what is weak for what strength it has, and use what is dim for the light it gives, then all will go well. This is called Acting Naturally."
Lao-Tsu, Tao Teh King
 
Posts: 2930 | Location: St Luke's Hospital, Bradford and Pinderfields Hospital, Wakefield | Registered: 14 December 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Chelle
Posted Hide Post
That's fantastic!
Lets hope they see sense!


-~*Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds*~-
...Albert Einstein
 
Posts: 758 | Location: Hastings, UK | Registered: 01 March 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Dr Vinod K Joshi
Posted Hide Post
Appraisal Committee's preliminary recommendations
  • Cetuximab in combination with radiotherapy is recommended as a treatment option only for patients with locally advanced squamous cell cancer of the head and neck whose Karnofsky performance-status score is 90% or greater and for whom all forms of platinum-based chemoradiotherapy treatment are contraindicated.
  • People currently receiving cetuximab in combination with radiotherapy for the treatment of locally advanced squamous cell cancer of the head and neck who do not meet the criteria outlined in section 1.1 should have the option to continue therapy until they and their clinicians consider it appropriate to stop


Note that this document does not constitute the Institute's formal guidance on this technology. The recommendations made in Section 1 are preliminary and may change after consultation.

Ref: http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/index.jsp?action=folder&o=39184
The key dates for this appraisal are:
Closing date for comments: 4 March 2008

Next Appraisal Committee meeting: 12 March 2008

Related News:

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Dr Vinod K Joshi,


Disclaimer: Please see your own dentist/doctor for a proper diagnosis as my words should not, in any circumstances, be taken as dental/medical advice.

"If you see what is small as it sees itself, and accept what is weak for what strength it has, and use what is dim for the light it gives, then all will go well. This is called Acting Naturally."
Lao-Tsu, Tao Teh King
 
Posts: 2930 | Location: St Luke's Hospital, Bradford and Pinderfields Hospital, Wakefield | Registered: 14 December 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  
 


Mouth Cancer Foundation is a registered charity No. 1109298.
Registered as a company limited by guarantee in England & Wales No. 5154295.
Copyright © 2002-2004 Dr Vinod K Joshi BDS DRDRCS FDSRCPS. All Rights Reserved.